Stop & Shop Gas Station Wins Round One

An application to build a gas station and kiosk at 528 Monroe Turnpike received inland wetlands approval Wednesday.

Plans for a five-bay gas station with a kiosk serving customers at 528 Monroe Turnpike weathered strong opposition from neighbors and environmentalists during a hearing before the Inland Wetlands Commission, which granted its unanimous approval at a special meeting on Wednesday night.

The applicant, Monroe Gas LLC, now needs to go before the Planning & Zoning Commission in its bid to make the new gas station a reality.

Stephen Studer, the attorney hired by the applicant, was pleased with the Inland Wetlands Commission's decision, which included a laundry list of conditions that must be met.

"I think they were very thorough and comprehensive in the analysis of the application," Studer said. "They did a great job. It was the correct decision in view of the expert testimony."

As the reason for approval, Chairman Jeremy Hayden said that experts working for both the applicant and the commission indicated there would be no adverse impact on the wetlands and watercourses.


Interested in Monroe's news, events, community bulletins, blogs and businesses? Sign up for the free Monroe Patch daily newsletter, "like" us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.


However, a number of townspeople have expressed concerns about having a gas station on the 1.9-acre property, because Beardsley Brook runs behind it and empties into Far Mill River on its way to Shelton Reservoir, which is owned by Aquarion Water Co.

Some worry about potential runoff from contaminated soil being disturbed when an old fuel tank is dug up and the gas tanks are installed. The land was used as a home-heating oil terminal from 1962-1988 and — despite clean up efforts — the soil is still polluted from oil spills over the years.

Engineers and environmental experts hired by the applicant have touted a state-of-the-art drainage plan for the property and promised to take precautions when lowering the water table to remove and install tanks.

Aquarion Water Co. had written a letter in opposition of the gas station because of its close proximity to public drinking water. The Drinking Water Division of the Connecticut Department of Energy & Environmental Protection has also said it is a bad idea to build a gas station near a public water supply watershed.

Disappointed Neighbors

About a dozen people in opposition to the project had gathered in back of the Council Chambers of Monroe Town Hall during deliberations, and some wore grim expressions when it became clear that the commission was going to approve the gas station. But those interviewed by Patch afterward appeared to be upbeat.

"Here we go to Planning & Zoning," Gail Bunovsky said with a smile. "P&Z is for health, safety and the general welfare of the community. This is a gas station in a public supply watershed."

Aside from the public water supply, Bunovsky, who is vice chairman of the Conservation & Water Resources Commission in town, noted how private wells are also fed by water in the area.

Leon Ambrosey, who owns a service station on Route 111, visited Ahold's website, Ahold owns Stop & Shop. It's president and CEO, Cees van der Hoeven, says on the site, "We aspire to be an environmentally responsible company in every market where we operate."

Ambrosey said, "They're supposed to be environmentally friendly. I don't know why they want to put a gas station within 50 feet of a watercourse for public drinking water."

He said he reached out to the company about the application to build a gas station in Monroe and that a woman in Adold's environmental department has yet to return his phone call.

Ambrosey noted how Ahold has cleaned up brown fields to build stores before and questioned why it did not fund a clean up of the Monroe site.

"They said they work with the community and they haven't worked with anybody in the community," he said. "Nor have they addressed any adverse conditions."

Conditions of approval

Inland Wetlands Commission members' approval included a lengthy list of conditions, among them were:

  • Obtaining an easement for the septic system
  • Receiving a report from the Trumbull-Monroe Health District
  • Sizing information must be provided for the oil/water separator
  • The drainage system must contain the first inch of runoff from the impervious areas
  • A final materials management plan must be submitted prior to the start of work, detailing removal and replacement of unsuitable fill
  • Plantings must be maintained for three years with a follow up report from an appropriate professional. Plantings will be bonded for and monitored.
  • There must be an increase in landscaping buffer to the east and south-east along the river
  • A construction sequence plan must be provided to the town engineer prior to construction
  • There must be verification of a DEEP permit for water table discharge before construction
  • The de-watering tank must be kept as far away from the wetlands as possible
  • Water taken out of the ground as tanks are being installed must be trucked away from the site
  • There must be a maintenance plan for the cleaning of the stormwater drainage system, which must be cleaned out at 25 percent accumulation
  • Town Engineer Scott Schatzlein recommended a $40,000 performance bond
  • Cut off lighting is required for the site
  • A two-foot-high rock wall will prevent amphibians from entering the vernal pool area in the drainage system
  • The applicant must remove as much sediment as possible from the tributary
  • Debris must be removed from the site on a scheduled basis
  • Snow plowed after storms of two inches or less will be piled on the north side of the site and higher accumulations must be trucked off the site
  • A crushed stone berm is required
  • There must be curbing around the Dumpster pad
  • The gas station will only be open when the Stop & Shop supermarket on Route 111 is open
  • An existing well must be properly abandoned
  • The application must be changed to reflect disturbance of the wetlands by the plunge pool

The commission will also make a referral to the P&Z Commission recommending that no petroleum-based products other than gasoline be sold on the property.

donna miller July 12, 2012 at 11:07 AM
that will make 5 gas stations within 1/4 mile.... do we really need it ?
Tman July 12, 2012 at 11:36 AM
Yes, we need it, you see how much the gas in monroe is compared to surrounding towns, stop & shop will have lower prices and that will force the competion to lower their prices
Maggie July 12, 2012 at 12:26 PM
and than maybe the small gas stations will close and go out of business and than S&S can up the prices again.
Alex July 12, 2012 at 01:24 PM
Do you have evidence of that happening in other communities? Every Stop and Shop gas station I've been to is substantially cheaper than the surrounding gas stations. Tack on their rewards card savings and it can be 30-40 cents cheaper per gallon than surrounding stations. That type of savings is enough for me to drive past gas stations to go to this one.
Steve Kirsch July 12, 2012 at 02:18 PM
I understand all of the conditions except the hours of operations. What is the logic there and why is that type of condition a matter for this commission to decide?
PlumbBob July 12, 2012 at 02:48 PM
There is already a Shell station next door to this property and just up the road in Trumbull. Why hasn't there been any mention of this? You can currently get your Stop & Shop discounts there can't you? And you would be thinking foolishly to believe this is going to cause local stations to lower their prices. Oh yeah, if you don't have all those S&S points for the discount guess what, your paying the same prices for fuel as the other local stations anyway! I will refuse to purchase anything from Stop & Shop or this station should it be approved and urge all opposing town members to do the same. And once again, no mention of the potential traffic problems this will create in a narrow two lane stretch of Rt 111. I sure hope P&Z considers that. I really hope that CT DEEP finds some problem with this and squashes it. Everyone is worried about saving a few dollars per tank full and that seems more important to them than the potential contamination of a watershed and the increased traffic conditions they will face on a daily basis. Ridiculous.
Josh July 12, 2012 at 04:15 PM
Agreed. What Monroe really needs is something other than Pizza, banks or gas stations.
Bill Bittar (Editor) July 12, 2012 at 06:01 PM
That's so if there is a spill or something at the gas station, someone at the store can be contacted during its business hours.
Concernedparent July 12, 2012 at 06:38 PM
Yeah!!! Stop & Shop gas prices are equal to Costco and BJ's...the cheapest around! It's about time someone or something brought competition to the prices we are paying on 111 or 25!!! I hate using the discount points when the price per gallon is .20 cents higher than at S & S's in Milford or Derby! I can't wait to get my gas here in Monroe!!! So happy about this and anyone that buys gas should be, too!!!
Concernedparent July 12, 2012 at 06:39 PM
And...Stop & Shop also charges the same price for cash or credit, too!!! So happy this is a good thing!!
QWERTY July 12, 2012 at 07:12 PM
"...promised to take precautions..." What the hell does that mean?! "Promise"?! This town has a laundry list of conditions for this project yet we're going on "promising" that the applicants don't contaminate our drinking water?! This isn't a town issue, it's a regional issue. Every person served by the Shelton Reservoir is put in danger. I'm pro-business but this we can do without. A fifth gas station in the area is not needed. The four existing gas stations have terrible prices as it is.
barbara July 12, 2012 at 08:02 PM
We do not need another gas station along that stretch, let them build it in Newtown or Trumbull.
Chief Waldo July 12, 2012 at 09:47 PM
I'm in favor of it.
JoAnn Toth July 13, 2012 at 01:28 AM
I would rather see a nice upscale Coffee House at that location. Would be nice to see something different for a change. Another gas station??? Come on... really?? Hey Monroe....knock, knock, knock..... when are you going to wake up??!!
mark antinozzi July 13, 2012 at 01:38 AM
There used to be a cartoon in the Sunday papers called "Gasoline Alley", I guess we can use this label for this stretch of Rt. 111, as we will have 5 gas/service stations within a half-mile section of road. Once S & S undercuts the local gas stations, there will be 4 used car stations and one gas station. Guess what will happen to the prices then???? I'm sure this is what everyone wants...one gas station and 4 used car lots. Wonderful, what an image !!!! I hope they all have wooden guard rails to give them a proper "Monroe" image.
Bobbie July 13, 2012 at 03:36 AM
In all good conscience, I cannot accept the fact that we would sell the real possibility of ground and water contamination for a few cents less in cost per gallon to fill the gas tank. Our biggest concern is the health of our families and not the wealth of Stop and Shop.
Christine E. July 13, 2012 at 05:02 PM
It isn't so much about 'want' or 'need'. It's about who is willing to put up capital and open businesses in Monroe. I don't think we 'need' another gas station either. I would like to 'see' a lot of things open in Monroe - but where are the investors willing to put up capital on these great ideas? Upscale coffee house? Sounds good! Who do you have lined up to make that a reality? Keep dreaming...


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »